Ina Had a White House Office and a $20 Billion Budget. Then She Traded It for a 400-Square-Foot Food Shop

Hi all! For several months I have mentioned that I am going to be launching a new micronewsletter, “The Shoestring Marketing Minute.” Well, procrastination time is finally over 😬 and we are launching.

It’s going to be short, fun, quick read. A few sentences, a few great links, and tata! If you are looking for the useful, unexpected, easy, and super affordable ways to grow your business, this is it.

I really think you will love it, and if not, unsubscribing will be easy, and no hard feelings (I promise!) Look for it a few times a week, starting Saturday. All feedback welcome!

It was Memorial Day weekend, 1978, and Ina Garten’s brand new, first effort specialty food store in Westhampton Beach had just had its first full day of business.

She was so excited!

But then it grossed just $87.

Six weeks earlier, Ina had been a nuclear energy budget analyst at the White House. She had an MBA and a career that looked terrific on paper. But after four years of working on projects worth $20 billion, but projects that never really seemed to move, she had quietly lost her mind with boredom.

 Then she saw the ad.

 A specialty food store in the Hamptons was for sale.

“The Stupidest Thing I Have Ever Done.”

One look at the 400-square-foot shop and she made an offer on the spot. The owner, Diana Stratta, countered. They negotiated for four hours and settled on $20,000. Ina called her husband from the car on the way home:

“This may be the stupidest thing I have ever done,” she told him, “but it was also so exhilarating.”

Ina had never run a store. Her entire food experience was the dinner parties she threw for Washington friends.

Not the best training, that.

And now, at the end of day one, she had that $87 and a sinking feeling.

Diana, the previous owner, had agreed to stay for a month and teach Ina the ropes. After that, she was on her own. The clock was ticking. If she could not figure this out fast, she was going to lose her investment and go crawling back to Washington with nothing to show for the boldest thing she had ever done.

The Wrong Instinct

Ina did what years in Washington had trained her to do. She was trying to impress people.

She arranged her roasted chickens on a beautiful white platter, set on a bed of fresh herbs. It looked like something out of a magazine. Customers walked in, looked at it, and walked right back out.

She stocked things she thought her customers should want. She made elegant presentations. She brought a bureaucrat’s take to a small business problem: “Here is the right answer, now accept it.”

And the store stayed quiet. Too quiet. The money kept draining.

20 Minutes That Changed Everything

Then Ina stopped talking and started watching.

Her customers were Hamptons vacationers. They were heading to the beach, to picnics, to backyards with friends and they did not want a restaurant experience. They wanted, as Ina would later put it, “the best home cooking without the trouble of making it at home.”

They wanted to feel taken care of - not impressed.

So Ina pulled the chickens off the white platter and put each one in a red-and-white paper container instead.

She sold out in twenty minutes.

The containers said what no beautiful platter ever could: “Take me to the beach! Eat me with your hands! I am not trying to impress you!”

Ina rebuilt the whole store around that single insight. She stopped deciding what customers should want and started giving them what they actually did want. The new menu tasted like the best home cooking money could buy.

 Yep, business exploded.

The next summer, only her second, Ina expanded into a space across the street. It was ten times the size of the original. 18 years later, the store, a name Ina had inherited from Diana, “The Barefoot Contessa,” was a destination for celebrities and Hamptons elite alike.

Ina Garten closed the store in 1996, wrote her first cookbook, landed on the Food Network, and built a brand now worth $60 million.

All it took was listening to her customers at the moment it mattered most.

The Takeaway

Here is a pattern I have seen over and over again when I coach entrepreneurs: We fall in love with what we think our customers should want. We design the beautiful platter. We stock the things that impress us. We tell the market what it ought to like.

Magic Johnson says he did the exact same thing with his first business, a sporting goods store called Magic 32. It went bankrupt because, Magic says, “I stocked it with stuff I liked, not things my customers liked.”

Ina Garten figured out in her first month that the customer is not wrong. They are telling you something. The entrepreneurs who win are the ones who stop talking long enough to hear it.

Your customers are sending you signals right now. The question is whether you are listening . . . or still rearranging the platter.

Steal This Strategy

🛠️ Listen: Ina Garten on Fresh Air (NPR). Terry Gross sits down with Ina about her memoir, her bold career leap, and the choices that defined her life. 47 great minutes.

 📚 Read: Be Ready When the Luck Happens: A Memoir by Ina Garten. The full story of how a government analyst became a culinary icon - and the mindset behind every decision she made.

 🎙️ Podcast: Be My Guest with Ina Garten. Ina interviews extraordinary people about food, home, and living well. One of the warmest shows going.

 📅 Meet: Want Me to Create and/or Write Your Newsletter For You? A month ago, I launched a new newsletter for a fellow Notes reader - a coach with a PhD - and her readership has gone up every week since. Maybe it’s your time to turn your expertise into attention, and money. Book a free discovery call with me.

About Steve

Steve Strauss is the best-selling author of The Small Business Bible (and 17 other books), Inc.’s small business columnist, a lawyer (non-practicing), and an entrepreneur. He sold his last venture, TheSelfEmployed.com to Mark Cuban & Zen Business. Need a ghostwriter or a newsletter for your business? Contact Steve!